The so-called ‘Mommy Wars’ are raging. While most of us average mothers just struggle with motherhood in the way best for them, there are those who insist that they have the only correct way to be a good parent. I’m pretty sure that sometime during their pregnancy, their hormone-riddled brain just stopped working the way it used to. Who am I kidding; this happens to all of us. But for this select few, the mother instinct seems to morph into the bitch instinct, and they have an urge to proclaim that their shit has lost its odor. These women are the generals of the war that none of us should be fighting.
Here’s my first (and for the time only) example: Amy Sohn. Maybe you’ve heard of her, maybe not. I don’t know who she is, but she’s apparently a writer. Oh, and a mother, but I’m not too sure she wants you to know that. This link was being circulated by the mom’s group I’m in, and to be sure, the woman has a unique ability to combine hatred and disdain on a website: http://www.amysohn.com/askamy/2006/summer06.htm
Ms. Sohn is quite apparently of the notion that only working mothers have any sense, and that those of us at home with our children are little poop-cleaning drones who are wasting our lives. She must be bosom-buddies with Linda Hirshman. Well, Ms. Sohn, this is what I think. True, I’m not completely college-educated (working on it), and I don’t exactly stay home completely by choice, but oh well. This is what I think of your classist, racist, and baseless point of view:
I am not brain-dead. I read the news online everyday, and I often watch Fox News at night. I used to be in the intel business, and motherhood has failed to erase the spark of world event-curiosity from my mind. If I’m not boning up on the latest events, I’m probably reading. On good days, I’ll read between 500-600 pages a day. I’m not reading much now because I’ve read all the books in our house. I do cross-stitch. I’ve been doing that for years. I like to craft with my hands instead of sitting idle while my kids play. Over the years I’ve learned several languages, and my kids hear English and Russian on a daily basis. My twins have the benefit of long, leisurely lunches, and my daughter has the time to engage in whatever activities suit her pleasure (usually drawing or Dora). I, on the other hand, pick and choose which chores to neglect so that I may pursue my personal interests (blogging). Free time is for the childless.
If I get the pleasure of meeting another mother, the subject of our children naturally comes up. This is because at first glance the only thing I might have in common with her is that fact that we indeed do have offspring. An obvious deviation from this is if I’m at a place without my kids, which is rare and therefore more appreciated. I digress. As this preliminary conversation gets flowing, we learn more about each other. Some women choose not to befriend others who have radically different parenting styles; there’s too much room for disagreement later. Meeting other mother friends is like dating. You don’t rush right in and start talking about 10 years from now. You get to know her. Sometimes, you come across a new mother who is scared and feels alone among all the older, more experienced moms. It’s good to reassure her she’s not harming her baby if she’s not feeding solids/resents the baby/trying to maintain a bit of her old self. Mothers need to stick together, because we’re raising the next generation of parents ourselves.
Ah, speaking of raising kids… I will not ‘out-source’ child care. Well, I won’t out-source to a personal nanny. One, we don’t have the money. My husband’s meager paycheck covers the basics, and in the end with three kids we don’t have enough to put the kids in care unless I was making a chunk o’ change. I’ll touch on this in a minute. Two, I don’t have the time to do the careful research to make sure the nanny is completely legal. Three, there are no Tibetan nannies down my way. And it’s not Tibet’s job to send citizens over here to raise my kids. They do spend a bit of time with me during the day, but I don’t always play with them. The twins are old enough to interact with the older girl, and so that frees up time to tackle the dishes or the laundry, or more likely the next several chapters of a book. I resent the fact that you believe I’m passing down whatever neuroses you think I have down into my children. Yes, I’m a tad crazy, and I used to be on Zoloft. I’m crazy because I am. There’s no helping that. I am receiving treatment for Post-partum Depression. I don’t know if you’ve heard of it, but it happens to a lot of moms. I delayed treatment for the better part of 7 months because I thought it signified failure on my part. My failing was not getting help.
One of the things I have done to get myself right again was to apply to college. I need a more usable degree path than the Russian language credits I have obtained, but unfortunately I didn’t get in. I’m applying to a community college now and I’ll start there. I tried getting a full-time job, but whoring a security clearance in my area is an exercise in futility (unless you have a master’s degree or ship-building knowledge). My husband and I even discussed me moving back to the Beltway to work up there. He’d keep the kids. I didn’t want to live away from my husband, and we set that option aside. Have you gathered the gist of this part yet, Ms. Sohn? I am not a SAHM because of choice-feminism, I’m here because I don’t have a viable alternative. Neither do thousands of other SAHMs. In fact, I harbor an extreme distaste for feminism. I abhor such radical thought, because it’s been corrupted and misused by people like Linda Hirshman. I’ll bitch and moan and groan about my lack of a job right now, mostly because I terribly miss mine. However, I was military, and I’m not able to get back in (bad knee). My husband is military, and since we move every so often, for us it’s best for me to be home.
I’m trying to remember if I’ve covered everything I wanted to, but sleep-deprivation is fogging my memory. I don’t envy you. Not one bit. I read your writing and wonder how you became a published person. I look at your opinion of your child’s care-giver, and it screams elitism. I’m sure she enjoys the cable, though. I can’t help but to wonder where you go for comfort if your child is acting strange. I know you lean on your nanny, but do you worry? Do you care? I wonder why you chose to reproduce if you’re so happy with your career and you can’t be bothered by your own daughter. Let me put it this way: Motherhood is something precious, and at the same time draining. It’s hard work. Being a mother changes not just your body and way of life, it physically rewires the pathways of the brain. It causes you to hear every little squeak in the middle of the night, the ability to handle to work diaper ever, the ‘maternal instinct’ as they say. Most moms worry about silly things, because to them, their child is the most precious being alive. This is not the result of being batty; it’s called love. You seem to treat motherhood as a burden, something to be dealt with by those poorer than you. Women who have education and money should not be bothered with a sick baby; that’s what immigrants are for. Children who are loved grow up to be loving people themselves. One day your daughter is going to Google your name and see that when she needed you, she was tossed to the nanny. She’ll notice that she’s not the important thing in your life, your job is. Sure, not every SAHM does the right thing either. Nobody’s perfect. So, Ms. Sohn, enjoy your career. Try to find time to enjoy your daughter. Just remember these two things: Your daughter will be grown up before you know it, and Ann Coulter would wipe the floor with you.
Now, if you’d all excuse me, I have a shower to take, dishes to do, and a playdate to prepare for in the next 30 minutes. I’ll see if I can squeeze that into my leisure time.